Get

In Your Inbox

Dogster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Would I Be Friends With My Dogs If They Were People? Probably Not

Share

Jelly the dog

Hi, I’m Allison! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my three mixed-breed dogs from Thailand, Jelly, Lorraina, and Manic.

Dogs have always been seen as the ideal companions for people. While some breeds are mainly used as working dogs, their loyalty and dedication remain unmatched. People who have dogs as pets consider them family members and believe that if they were people, they would be best friends.

However, when I think about my dogs and their individual personalities, I really struggle to believe we would be best friends if they were people. To be honest, I don’t think I would like them at all.divider dog paws 4 oct 2024

Jelly: The Clingy Bestie Who Cannot Survive Without You

On the surface, Jelly seems like the perfect introverted friend. You know the ones I am talking about—the friend who does not want to go to a restaurant but would much rather get a pizza and binge-watch the latest TV series. Jelly would be the friend who would exercise with you out of love but is completely fine lounging in bed all day. She is not high-maintenance and has no embarrassing habits.

But since Jelly is a Velcro dog, she would be the clingy friend. A very clingy friend.

If Jelly were human, I could imagine her texting me every 10 minutes to ask me what I was doing. If I were to hang out with someone else for a few hours, she would make me feel guilty about it—maybe even start crying because I was ditching her and getting a new BFF. If Jelly and I were to go to a party or a bar, I know she would follow me continuously, even if I went to the restroom. She would also drop hints that she would want to go home after being out for 30 minutes.

Jelly, as a person, would need constant reassurance about your friendship but will still doubt your loyalty.

Lorraina: Always Looking for Trouble or a Fight

Lorraina sitting outside
Lorraina is a bit of a troublemaker

Lorraina is not a fan of other dogs. She was not like this when she was younger, but due to her small size, she got picked on by other dogs. This fueled her rage and made her distrustful of other dogs—no matter what size. She is wonderful with people, but if she sees another dog, she is going after them.

This would make having Lorraina as a friend very difficult. I can imagine us walking around, and if someone accidentally steps on her foot, she is going to punch them in the face without hesitation. If we would go to a bar and someone looked at her for too long, I bet she would grab the nearest beer bottle and smash them over the head. Lorraina would definitely be that person who would pull the fire alarm in a building or slip an unpurchased item into someone’s bag to set off the security alert at a store.

Legally, it would be unwise to have Lorraina as a friend.

Manic: Partying Like It Is 1999…All the Time

Manic sitting outside
Manic has truly earned his name!

Manic is usually high-energy and is up for anything and everything! As long as it was not raining, he would spend the whole day outside, chasing chipmunks and squirrels, digging holes, and running around like crazy.

As a human friend, Manic would be up until the crack of dawn. He would be the type of person who shows up at your house at 10 pm and tells you about an underground party that is about to start. He would be the type of person who would do donuts in a parking lot or skinny dip in a neighbor’s pool. Manic would live life to the fullest at full volume.

If Manic got caught doing things he shouldn’t have, he would use his charm and looks to try to get out of the situation. He would flash a smile and run his fingers through his hair, saying things like, “Gee, I didn’t know how loud I was being” or “Gosh, I didn’t know what the speed limit was on this road.” But the next day, he was out again, running red lights, breaking into amusement parks, or doing keg stands.

Manic would be, simply put, too exhausting for me to befriend.

Do I Even Like My Dogs if I Don’t Want Them as Friends?

Of course. Without a question. I love each of my dogs and their personalities because they are dogs. Yes, Jelly is a Velcro dog, and I almost trip over her because she follows me around. But I love her. Yes, Lorraina will lunge at any dog that isn’t Jelly or Manic, hoping to draw blood. But I love her. And, yes, Manic lives his life with his paw on the gas pedal. But I love him.

However, if they were people, I would have to pass on building friendships with them.

This article is a part of Allison, Jelly, Lorraina, and Manic's series.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything dog

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.




How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Dogster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.


Dogster's Digital Magazine is Back!​

Dogster Magazine Cover June 2026

Vet-approved health & behavior advice

Real dog stories & community features

Ask Dr. Paola- Help! My Vet Suggests a Biopsy for My Dog! (June 15, 2026)

Welcome to our “Ask Dr. Paola” series, where every Monday we bring expert advice straight from Dr. Paola Cuevas (MVZ) to help our...

Why Some Dogs Treat Mealtime Like Playtime – And When to Pay Attention

Most dogs are reliable eaters. Bowl goes down, food disappears. So when a dog starts batting kibble across the kitchen floor, tossing pieces...

Major Win for Dogs: Ontario Becomes the Final Province to Ban Ear Cropping and Debarking

​​Ontario has approved new animal welfare regulations that will prohibit elective ear cropping and devocalization (debarking) procedures in dogs from January 1, 2027....

Dogster’s Weekly Photo Contest Winners: Most Adorable Puppy (June 8, 2026)

Every week our team gets the privilege of sorting through our readers photos to choose what dogs will win this weeks contest! See...

More related

3 Amazing Portuguese Water Dog Haircuts (With Pictures)

With curly hair and a single hypoallergenic coat like the Poodle, the Portuguese Water Dog doesn’t shed. The trade-off is that they require...

Imo-Inu (American Eskimo and Shiba Inu Mix): Info, Pictures, Care & More

Have you seen an Imo-Inu? These dogs are not only cute but friendly, too. They have an infectious happy temperament and are pleasant...

Imodium for Dogs: Is It Okay to Give Your Dog OTC Human Medicine? (Vet Answer)

Let's talk Imodium for dogs — can you give a dog Imodium for his upset stomach? Are other OTC human meds like Kaopectate...

Lepto Vaccine for Dogs: What to Know & Side Effects (Vet Answer)

Vaccinations generally provide good protection for your dog against certain diseases that could be severe and debilitating. While no vaccine leads to 100%...

Keep reading

Why Do Dogs Bury Their Food? Vet-Verified Reasons & What to Do

Have you ever seen your dog try to bury their food? Maybe they take a treat and run to the backyard or drag a food bowl over to somewhere where they can dig. This behavior might be baffling on the...

small dog digging

Dog Feeding Schedule for Puppies, Adults & Senior Dogs (Vet Approved)

In addition to determining how much to feed your dog, establishing a feeding schedule can also be very beneficial. This means feeding your dog at roughly the same time every day, according to how many meals they need and how...

golden retriever dog eating healthy dry food from bowl at home

10 Best Dry Dog Foods in 2026 – Reviews & Top Picks

Dry dog food is convenient, long-lasting, and easy to store. It’s also highly nutritious, making it the most popular option for many pet parents. Of course, with this popularity comes a myriad of different brands on the market, some of...

measures a portion of dry dog food using an electronic scale

Is Grain-Free Dog Food Better for Dogs? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts

Dogs are omnivores and therefore should eat a wide variety of different foods. This is why many commercial dog food brands have grains in their formulas. However, there are nearly as many “non-traditional” food options on the market that do...

dry dog food in a bowl on wooden table

Meridian Dog Food Review 2026: Pros, Cons, Recalls, and FAQ

Review Summary Meridian is a holistic pet food company that is made by Midwestern Pet Foods under the parent company Nunn Milling Co. Meridian makes four different dog food recipes with an aim at high quality, natural nutrition. We all...

Dogster_Meridian Dog Food Review

Can Dogs Be Vegan? Vet Approved Advice & Safety Tips

Responsible dog owners always want to make smarter, more ethical choices to improve their pet’s physical and mental well-being. With growing awareness around the eco-sustainability and health perks of vegetarian and vegan diets, it’s natural to wonder how a change...

The dog sits near a bowl of food and licks his tongue, dry food and fresh vegetables and fruits

How Long Does A Dog Usually Have Diarrhea After Changing Food? Vet-Verified Facts

It’s alarming to wake up to your dog having diarrhea. A million scenarios can quickly run through your mind, wondering what the cause of their runny stool may be. Are they sick? Have they eaten something they shouldn’t have? Do...

dog with a food bowl

4Health Dog Food Review 2026: Pros, Cons, Recalls & FAQ

If you don’t have a Tractor Supply Co. in your area, you might not have heard of their private label dog food brand, 4Health. The brand offers limited ingredient foods that include real meat and veggies in both grain-free and...

Dogster_4Health Dog Food Review

Love Dogs? So Do We! Join the Dogster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.




Sign up for the Dogster Email Newsletter